Threads / Who thinks Melky Cabrera will be a Hall of Famer?

Posted in MLB Baseball / New York Yankees
« Older  Rasner In the future  Newer »

MT30

Morristown, NJ

4505.75 Points
Level 3: Veteran
Ignore User
Who thinks Melky Cabrera will be a Hall of Famer?

posted on 10/5/08

Reply
Replies (18)
Reply to this thread

twac00

tenafly, NJ

17655.00 Points
Level 5: Hall of Famer
Ignore User
No one.

posted on 10/5/08

MNTWINSFAN

Perham, MN

4435.00 Points
Level 3: Veteran
Ignore User
I second that.

posted on 11/5/08

ChiTownChief

Photobucket, IL

2571.75 Points
Level 3: Veteran
Ignore User
Yeah no way!

posted on 11/5/08

fantasyyankees123

An area penetrating the state of, NY

129094.75 Points
Level 8: Immortal
Ignore User
too early to tell!

posted on 10/5/08

sturdi

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

, MN

8056.25 Points
Level 4: All Star
Ignore User
I do not think so

posted on 10/5/08

beachlady

HHI, SC

60874.75 Points
Level 7: Icon
Ignore User
It might be a bit premature, but I think he has the tools to get him there. time will tell whether he applies them

posted on 10/5/08

dougbies

chicago, IL

84572.75 Points
Level 7: Icon
Ignore User
hahah... nobody except 12 year old yankee fans.

posted on 10/5/08

MT30

Morristown, NJ

4505.75 Points
Level 3: Veteran
Ignore User
Hey, I never said he will make it to the hall of fame.

posted on 10/5/08

dougbies

chicago, IL

84572.75 Points
Level 7: Icon
Ignore User
yeah, i did not even notice your age when i posted that.... i was just assuming that younger yankee fans would be the only ones to think that he will be a hall of famer...

posted on 10/5/08

Gomes31

Coatesville, PA

2038.00 Points
Level 3: Veteran
Ignore User
I saw a little leaguer who looked pretty good today....how about him? Hall of Fame worthy? Too early to tell for the Melkman.

posted on 10/5/08

Onlinehail2daredskinz

Joba Chamberlain, NJ

69418.50 Points
Level 7: Icon
Ignore User
thats very unlikely altho theres three possible things that can help him:

1- he started his career very early, he could easily amass 3000 hits.

2- hes great defensively. 3000 hits + gold gloves is a solid HOF resume. plus his power and speed arent bad- he'll hit about 300-400 homers.

3- hes a yankee, lol so you know he'll get the votes especially if he wins a few championships with the team.


as of right now, he certainly does not project.

posted on 11/5/08

JacobyTheGreat

Lewisburg, PA

639.50 Points
Level 2: Starter
Ignore User
Sure, but he'd have to become a REAL good manager.

posted on 11/5/08

don23mattingly

taylor, MI

82857.00 Points
Level 7: Icon
Ignore User
melky you were rained out today and you have too much time on your hands now go to sleep..

posted on 11/5/08

zeus8822

Chesapeake, VA

1725.00 Points
Level 2: Starter
Ignore User
if he turns into arod over night

posted on 11/5/08

zeus8822

Chesapeake, VA

1725.00 Points
Level 2: Starter
Ignore User
if he turns into arod over night

posted on 11/5/08

ill orange

New York, NY

12362.25 Points
Level 5: Hall of Famer
Ignore User
way to early to tell... as of now i would say no

posted on 11/5/08

wheels60

colonia, NJ

2701.50 Points
Level 3: Veteran
Ignore User
WHAT A JOKE. TO EARLY TO SAY THAT

posted on 12/5/08

Deanna17

Hartford, CT

1251.50 Points
Level 2: Starter
Ignore User
As much as I absolutly love him, it's too early to tell.

posted on 13/5/08

Replies (18)
Reply to this thread